Independent directors play a very important role in transparency, accountability, and good governance in any corporate body. In India, with the changed regulatory scenario, SEBI and the Companies Act of 2013 have been accorded greater importance to independent directors. An independent director comes with an unbiased view of corporate affairs and brings decisions that work in the best interest of its shareholders as well as all stakeholders.
Are you interested in pursuing a career in Law? The Legal School in collaboration with IndusLaw has created unique programs for a Certification in Mergers & Acquisitions, Private Equity and Venture Capital Laws & Certification in Mergers & Acquisitions for fresh law graduates as well as professionals looking to advance in their careers! Enquire now for details!
Definition of Independent Director
An independent director is an outsider of the board and not an executive director and does not have any material or pecuniary relationship with the company, its promoters, or its management. The intention behind this independent status is to avoid conflicts of interest and ensure objective, unbiased advice and decision-making on the part of the director.
Legal Provisions and Regulatory Framework
Legal provisions and a regulatory framework for the appointment of independent directors are available under the Companies Act, 2013, and SEBI regulations, which provide some essential criteria to ensure transparency, accountability, and corporate governance. These regulations protect the interest of the company against the conflict of interest by providing eligibility and roles of an independent director in a company.
1. Provisions under Companies Act, 2013
Underpinning all this is the Companies Act, of 2013. Section 149(6) of the said act stipulates qualifications and requirements for being an independent director. Therefore, a set of standards that qualify an independent director with characteristics of integrity and impartiality is established by the law.
2. SEBI Regulations
Listed entity obligations and disclosure requirements shall be under LODR. LODR regulations explicitly mention that out of the board, a given number must consist of independent directors, depending on the classification and size of the company.
Eligibility Criteria for Independent Directors
These conditions are prescribed to make sure that the directors appointed are independent.
No Monetary Association: The independent director must not have a monetary association with the firm, its subsidiaries, or any associated enterprise.
Qualifications: They are expected to provide the board with special knowledge and experience, making qualifications in finance, law, or management highly valued.
No Conflicting Interest: They must not have an existing or past employment relationship with the firm or any of its subsidiaries.
Also, learn about the Gratuity Act 1972.
Selection Process
At times, the independence of an independent director is ensured by making the process of appointment a stringent one. The standard procedure of doing so step by step is as follows:
Step 1: Identification of Candidates
The Nomination and Remuneration Committee identifies and filters potential candidates with the required skills, knowledge, and experience.
Step 2. Evaluation and Interview
Appointed candidates are interviewed and analyzed by the NRC. There, they declare any interests that might have a possible influence on the work of the board.
Step 3. Form Nomination
The nominated candidate is presented before the board for its deliberation, and upon agreement, that candidate is brought before shareholders for their endorsement at an AGM.
Step 4. Shareholder's Approval
The appointment of an independent director must be approved by the shareholders of the company through a majority vote in the AGM.
Want to pursue law? Check out the online law courses and fulfill your dreams.
Term and Tenure
The term of an independent director under the Companies Act, 2013 is generally not more than two consecutive terms of five years each. After two terms, the director must wait for a period of three years to be eligible for reappointment, thus bringing fresh insights to the board.
Roles and Responsibilities
Independent directors represent a very important role in the governance structure of an organization. Their role, among others, is described below:
Promote Ethical Conduct: Independent directors ensure that corporate decisions conform to ethical standards.
Protection of Stakeholder Interests: They protect the interests of shareholders and other stakeholders by providing oversight over critical decisions and transactions.
Serving on Committees: The independent directors usually chair or are members of the top committees, which include the Audit Committee, Nomination and Remuneration Committee, and Risk Management Committee.
Compliance Monitoring: The independent directors ensure that all applicable laws, including those on corporate governance and reporting of financials, are complied with.
Read to know corporate governance meaning.
Importance of Independent Directors in Corporate Governance
Independent directors confer many advantages, especially in regard to the improvement of corporate governance:
Improved Transparency: The independent oversight ensures that the corporate decisions are transparent and reduces the chances of fraud.
Equilibrium Balance in Decision Making: Through independent directors, the balanced interest of the shareholders, management, and stakeholders is struck.
Confidence of the Investors: A well-composed board with independent directors can make the investors confident because it is considered a sign of good governance.
Conflict Prevention: This is done by the participation of independent directors in some key committees, which highly reduces conflicts of interest within corporations.
Challenges in the Appointment of Independent Directors
Independent directors are essential but have always been confronted with challenges throughout the process of their selection and reselection:
Right candidates: It has remained a problem for several corporations as it involves having the right candidates who can spend a lot of time on service.
Conflicts of Interest: Even though the criteria for regulations are present, conflicts of interest still surface. This is highly probable in scenarios where independent directors have intimate relations with the promoters of the company.
High Expectations: Independent directors typically work under a lot of pressure, especially during periods of crisis. Their answerability can make the task onerous and perilous.
Regulatory Changes and Recent Reforms
Within the last few years, bodies like SEBI have been implementing reforms to upgrade the position of independent directors. Some examples are:
Stricter eligibility standards: New rules implemented have been far more stringent in regard to eligibility in order to avoid conflicts of interest and preserve independence
Shareholder sanction: SEBI has made it a rule that shareholder approval must be obtained for the appointment and reappointment of independent directors so that transparency is enhanced
Performance reviews: Independent directors are subject to performance reviews, conducted by the NRC, which are then approved by shareholders.
Best Practices when Selecting Independent Directors
In order to improve the quality of independent directors and to make them effective, the following best practices can be followed by companies:
Robust Nomination Process: The nomination process should be objective and have clear criteria in place that align with the strategic goals of the company.
Clear Role Definitions: Clear definitions of the roles and responsibilities of independent directors may help set realistic expectations and avoid potential conflicts.
Continuous Training and Development: Training on regulatory changes, industry trends, and corporate governance keeps independent directors well-informed and effective.
Periodic Performance Reviews: Regular reviews ensure that the independent directors are performing in line with their responsibilities and contribute meaningfully to the board.
Also, read about copyright law in India.
Independent Directors in the Indian Corporate Scenario
Independent directors have become increasingly significant in the Indian corporate sector. Reforms in corporate governance have seen a trend where more demands are arising for independent directors with much stronger governance and ethics skills. Their role in the companies of today is integral in dealing with risks, ensuring regulatory compliance, and building resilient, transparent organizations.
Conclusion
Independent directors have evolved as the cornerstone of corporate governance in India. The essence of regulation is transparency, accountability, and impartiality. To reap the rewards of experience and objectivity that independent directors bring on board, companies must achieve high standards in the process of selection and evaluation. Candidate scarcity, potential conflict, and high accountability make it imperative to address them to enhance their impact in corporate governance.
Independent directors will ultimately bridge the gap between management and stakeholders, guiding companies through complex governance landscapes and increasing investor trust. With the continuous reforms and the gradual development of corporate governance practices, the appointment of independent directors will continue to play a crucial role in shaping India's corporate future.
Appointment of Independent Director FAQs on
1. What is an independent director?
The independent director is the person who, other than any service or consideration or any material or pecuniary relationship with the company, its promoters, its management or its associates, does not enjoy any of these and also satisfies criteria in the Companies Act, 2013 and SEBI Regulations
2. What is so special about independent directors in corporate governance?
Independent directors are the ones who bring objective views, protect the interests of the shareholders, observe the regulatory requirements, and limit the incidence of conflict of interest in decision-making processes.
3. What are the qualification criteria for an independent director?
Independent directors should not have any direct pecuniary relationship with the company or its affiliates; they must have appropriate experience and knowledge and be eligible to satisfy the standards of independence under the rules prescribed by regulatory authorities.
4. How is an independent director appointed?
The process involves screening and nominating candidates by the Nomination and Remuneration Committee, approval by the board, and finally, shareholder approval at the annual general meeting (AGM).
5. What is the tenure of an independent director?
The independent director may serve not more than two successive terms of five years each as allowed under the Companies Act, 2013. Following such terms, three years should pass before appointment to those positions again.
