Asset valuation is a key part of preparing accurate financial statements, which show a company’s true financial health. In India, auditors follow the Companies Act, 2013, and the Standards on Auditing (SAs) set by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI). One important standard, SA 540 ("Auditing Accounting Estimates, Including Fair Value Accounting Estimates and Related Disclosures"), effective from April 1, 2009, guides auditors on how to check asset valuations to ensure they are correct and follow Indian laws.
Elevate your career with our Advanced Certification Program in Mergers & Acquisitions designed to transform your professional journey in just six months. This high- engagement course emphasizes real-world applications and features master classes from NLU and industry partners led by expert faculty.
Auditor’s Role in Asset Valuation
Auditors ensure that the values of assets in the financial statements of a company are accurate i,e. neither too high nor too low. This protects stakeholders, such as investors and creditors by ensuring the financial statements are reliable. The duties of auditor align with Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS) and Standards on Auditing (SAs), particularly SA 540, which focuses on checking estimates and including fair value measurements.
Given below is a clear breakdown of the auditor’s responsibilities, organized into key areas:
1. Checking If Assets Exist
Physical Verification: The auditor visits locations, like warehouses, to physically check assets, such as counting inventory to confirm that they actually exist.
Verifying Liabilities: The auditor contacts third parties like banks in order to confirm any debts or obligations tied to assets are properly recorded.
2. Confirming Ownership
Reviewing Documents: The auditor checks legal documents, such as property deeds, contracts or purchase agreements in order to ensure the company legally owns the assets.
Checking for Disputes: The auditor looks for any legal issues or claims that could challenge the company’s ownership of the assets.
3. Reviewing Valuation
Checking Valuation Methods: The auditor ensures that the methods of a company for valuing assets follow Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS).
Comparing Market Prices: The auditor compares the company’s asset values with current market prices to see if they are reasonable.
Evaluating Estimates: The auditor reviews the assumptions and methods of the company for estimating asset values in order to ensure that they are logical and fair.
4. Spotting Risks
Identifying Uncertainties: The auditor looks for areas where asset valuations, especially fair value estimates, might be uncertain or risky.
Deciding on Extra Checks: If valuations have high uncertainty, the auditor may perform additional tests to ensure accuracy.
5. Handling Risks
Reviewing Recent Events: The auditor checks if events happening up to the audit report date affect asset values.
Testing Estimates: The auditor examines how the company made its estimates and ensures the methods and assumptions are reliable.
Checking the Process: The auditor reviews the process of the company for creating estimates in order to ensure that it is consistent and trustworthy.
Creating Independent Estimates: The auditor may develop their own estimate or range of values to compare with the figures of the company in order to ensure that they align with standards.
6. Using Experts
Involving Specialists: For complex valuations such as specialized assets or fair value calculations, the auditor may consult experts, such as valuation professionals in order to gather reliable evidence.
7. Evaluating and Reporting
Assessing Accuracy: The auditor decides if the company’s asset valuations are correct based on the evidence collected.
Reporting Issues: If there are problems with valuations, the auditor informs the company and suggests corrections.
Ensuring Clear Disclosures: The auditor checks that the financial statements clearly explain important details, especially for risky estimates in order to maintain transparency.
8. Keeping Records and Following Rules
Documenting Findings: The auditor records their findings, especially for risky estimates or signs of bias from the company.
Getting Confirmation: The auditor asks the company for a written statement confirming that their estimates are reasonable.
Following Standards: The auditor adheres to widely accepted valuation practices, commercial standards, and Indian laws, including Ind AS and SAs.
Learn about more Income Tax Rules.
Legal and Standard Context
Under the Companies Act, 2013, auditors must ensure that financial statements, including asset valuations, present a true and fair view. SA 540 is key because it focuses on auditing accounting estimates, including fair value measurements, which are commonly used for assets like marketable securities, goodwill in business mergers, or impairment tests.
This standard applies to all companies, whether public or private, and ensures compliance with Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS).
For example, AS 30 defines fair value as “the amount for which an asset could be exchanged or a liability settled, between knowledgeable, willing parties in an arm’s length transaction.”
Auditors ensure that methods like independent appraisals or discounted cash flow calculations are used correctly, adjusting for market conditions or specific asset types, such as investment properties.
Practical Considerations
Auditors often rely on the company’s management or external experts for valuations but must do so carefully. For example:
Fixed Assets: These are usually valued at their original cost minus depreciation. The auditor checks if depreciation is calculated correctly.
Current Assets: Assets like inventory need close scrutiny for issues e.g., obsolescence or damage.
The auditor ensures the valuation basis (e.g., cost or market value) is clearly stated in the balance sheet and certified by company officials, such as directors or engineers.
Summary
Auditors in India have a comprehensive role in ensuring asset valuations are accurate and fairly presented in financial statements. Guided by SA 540 and other ICAI standards, they verify asset existence, ownership and valuation accuracy, ensuring compliance with Ind AS and protecting interests of stakeholders. This process maintains the trust and reliability of financial reporting in India.
Related posts
Duties of an Auditor Regarding Valuation of Assets: FAQs
Q1. What does an auditor do to check if assets actually exist?
The auditor physically inspects assets, like counting inventory in a warehouse, to confirm they exist. They also contact third parties, such as banks, to verify any debts or obligations tied to the assets are properly recorded.
Q2. How does an auditor ensure the company legally owns its assets?
The auditor reviews legal documents, like property deeds, contracts, or sale agreements, to confirm the company owns the assets. They also check for any legal disputes or claims that might affect ownership.
Q3. What steps does an auditor take to verify the value of assets?
The auditor checks if the company’s valuation methods follow Indian Accounting Standards (Ind AS). They compare asset values to market prices and review the company’s assumptions and methods to ensure they are reasonable and fair.
Q4. What happens if an auditor finds risks in asset valuation?
If the auditor finds uncertainties or risks, especially in fair value estimates, they may conduct extra tests. They review recent events up to the audit report date, test the company’s estimation process, and compare the company’s values with their own estimates to ensure accuracy.
Q5. Why does an auditor need to involve experts for asset valuation?
For complex assets or fair value estimates, the auditor may need help from specialists, like valuation experts, to ensure the evidence they collect is reliable and the asset values comply with standards.
