The Companies Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) is provides a lifeline for financially distressed companies to restructure their debts and avoid bankruptcy. Enacted in 1933 during the Great Depression, the CCAA has evolved into a flexible and effective tool for managing corporate insolvency. This article explains the CCAA in clear, simple terms, covering its purpose, process, benefits and real-world applications, making it accessible to business owners, creditors, employees and the general public.
Unlock new career opportunities with The Legal School’s Certification in Bankruptcy & Insolvency Law: Corporate Restructuring & Debt Resolution, in collaboration with IndusLaw. This six-month program, led by industry experts, equips you with critical skills in insolvency litigation, financial distress management and corporate rescue strategies. Earn a prestigious certificate and elevate your expertise in a rapidly evolving field!
What is the Companies Creditors Arrangement Act?
The Companies Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) is a federal law in Canada that allows insolvent corporations, those unable to pay their debts as they come due to reorganize their financial affairs. Unlike bankruptcy, which often leads to liquidation and the closure of a business, the CCAA focuses on restructuring. It enables companies to negotiate a "plan of arrangement" with their creditors, which might involve paying a portion of debts, extending payment timelines, or converting debt into equity (e.g., shares in the company).
The primary goal of the CCAA is to prevent the social and economic consequences of bankruptcy, such as job losses, reduced creditor recoveries and economic disruption. By allowing companies to continue operating, the CCAA helps preserve value for stakeholders and supports economic stability. The act is particularly suited for complex restructurings, offering more flexibility than the more rule-based Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (BIA).
Who Can Use the CCAA?
The CCAA is designed for larger corporations with significant debt. To qualify, a company must:
Be insolvent or facing financial difficulties.
Have total unsecured claims (debts not backed by collateral) exceeding $5 million, either alone or with its affiliates.
This $5 million threshold ensures the CCAA is used for cases where the economic impact of restructuring justifies the costs and complexity. Smaller companies with debts below this amount can use the Division I Proposal under the BIA which is a simpler process for smaller-scale restructurings.
The CCAA Process: Step by Step
The Companies Creditors Arrangement Act process is structured to balance the needs of the company, its creditors and other stakeholders. Here’s how it works:
1. Initial Application to Court
A company in financial distress files an application with a court, typically in the province where its head office is located. The application requests protection from creditors through a "stay of proceedings." This stay, initially granted for up to 10 days, prevents creditors from taking legal actions like lawsuits, asset seizures or debt collection. The court may extend the stay if the company shows progress toward a restructuring plan and is acting in good faith.
2. Appointment of a Monitor
The court appoints an independent monitor who must be a licensed insolvency trustee. The responsibilities of a monitor include:
Overseeing the operations of a company and financial affairs.
Ensuring the company acts in good faith and complies with court orders.
Assisting in developing the plan of arrangement.
Communicating with creditors and providing regular updates on the company’s financial situation.
The monitor acts as a neutral party which ensures transparency and fairness throughout the process.
3. Developing a Plan of Arrangement
The company, with the monitor’s assistance, creates a "plan of arrangement." This plan outlines how the company will address its debts. Possible solutions include:
Paying creditors a percentage of what they are owed (e.g., 50 cents on the dollar).
Extending payment terms to spread out debt repayment.
Converting debt into equity, giving creditors shares in the company.
Selling assets to raise funds.
The plan must be fair, reasonable and feasible along to balance the company’s need to survive with creditors’ rights to recover their money.
4. Creditor Voting
Creditors are divided into classes based on the nature of their claims (e.g., secured creditors with collateral, unsecured creditors without). Each class votes on the plan. For approval, the plan must receive:
A majority in the number of creditors (more than half of those voting).
At least two-thirds of the total value of claims in each class.
Creditors must file a "Proof of Claim" with the monitor to participate in the vote. A "claims bar date" may be set, after which late claims may not be considered.
5. Court Sanction
If creditors approve the plan, it is submitted to the court for final sanction. The court reviews the plan to ensure it:
Is fair and reasonable.
Complies with the Companies Creditors Arrangement Act and other legal requirements.
Respects prior court orders.
The court may reject the plan if it deems it unfair or unfeasible, even if creditors approve it. If sanctioned, the plan becomes binding on all creditors.
6. Implementation
Once approved, the company implements the plan, which may involve selling assets, securing new financing, or restructuring operations. If the plan fails or is not approved, the stay may be lifted, potentially leading to receivership or bankruptcy.
Key Provisions of the CCAA
The CCAA includes several critical provisions that guide the restructuring process. Below is a table summarizing the key provisions:
Section | Provision | Details |
3 | Application Threshold | Applies to companies with unsecured claims over $5 million. |
4, 5 | Creditor Meetings | Court may order meetings for unsecured or secured creditors to vote on the plan. |
6(1) | Creditor Approval | Requires majority in number and two-thirds in value of creditors to approve the plan. |
6(3) | Crown Claims | Crown claims (e.g., taxes) must be paid in full within 6 months unless creditors agree otherwise. |
6(5), 6(6) | Employee and Pension Payments | Requires immediate payment of certain employee wages and pension contributions post-sanction. |
11.02 | Stay of Proceedings | Initial stay up to 10 days, extendable as needed, halting creditor actions. |
19(2) | Excluded Claims | Claims like fines or damages for fraud cannot be compromised without creditor consent. |
23 | Monitor Duties | The monitor must publish notices, review cash flow, file reports and advise on plan fairness. |
36 | Agreement Disclaimer | Companies may terminate agreements with monitor and court approval, subject to conditions. |
These provisions ensure the process is transparent, equitable and legally sound, protecting the rights of all parties involved.
Role of Creditors
Creditors are integral to the CCAA process. The Companies Creditors Arrangement Act aims to treat creditors fairly, often providing better recovery than bankruptcy, where assets are sold off at a discount. They have the right to:
Be informed about the company’s financial situation through the monitor’s reports.
File a Proof of Claim to participate in voting.
Vote on the plan of arrangement.
Seek relief from the stay if it unfairly prejudices their interests.
Benefits of the CCAA
The CCAA offers some important benefits. By balancing these interests, the Companies Creditors Arrangement Act supports both individual companies and the broader economy:
For Companies: CCAA provides breathing room to restructure.
For Creditors: It provides better recovery than liquidation as the company continues generating value.
For Employees: It preserves jobs and reducing the social impact of business failure.
For the Economy: CCAA maintains economic stability by keeping businesses operational.
Historical Context
The CCAA was introduced in 1933 during the Great Depression, a time when business failures and unemployment were rampant. Existing laws like the Bankruptcy Act and Winding-Up Act focus on liquidation with often destroying value. The CCAA offered an alternative, allowing companies to restructure and survive. Over time, amendments in 1997, 2005 and 2009 enhanced its flexibility by addressing cross-border insolvencies and specific claim types. This makes it a robust tool for modern economic challenges.
Real-World Examples
The Companies Creditors Arrangement Act has been used by many Canadian companies. The cases given below highlight the versatility of CCAA. It supports both successful turnarounds and orderly wind-downs:
Air Canada: Filed for CCAA protection in 2003 and 2005, successfully restructuring its operations and emerging as a stronger airline.
Sears Canada: Used the CCAA in 2017 to attempt restructuring but ultimately liquidated due to insurmountable challenges.
Canwest Global Communications: Filed in 2009 during the financial crisis, using the CCAA to manage its debt and restructure its media operations.
Summary
The Companies Creditors Arrangement Act (CCAA) is a vital tool for managing corporate insolvency in Canada. By providing a flexible, court-supervised process, it helps companies restructure, preserves jobs and maximizes creditor recoveries. While not without complexity, the CCAA balances the needs of companies, creditors and employees, making it a cornerstone of Canada’s economic resilience. Whether helping a company like Air Canada recover or managing an orderly wind-down, the CCAA remains essential for navigating financial distress.
Related Posts:
Companies Creditors Arrangement Act: FAQs
Q1. What is the Companies Creditors Arrangement Act?
The CCAA is a Canadian law that helps insolvent companies owing over $5 million restructure their finances to avoid bankruptcy, under court supervision.
Q2. Who are the creditors under the Companies Act?
Creditors are people or entities a company owes money to, like suppliers, lenders, or bondholders, divided into secured (with asset-backed claims) and unsecured creditors.
Q3. How long does CCAA take?
The CCAA process starts with a 10-30 day stay, which can be extended by the court as needed, with no fixed time limit.
Q4. What does it mean when a company goes into creditor protection?
Creditor protection under the CCAA means a company gets a court-ordered pause from creditor actions to restructure its debts and continue operating.
