Administrative law and constitutional law form the two most fundamental branches of public law governing the activities of governments and their relationship with citizens. Notwithstanding the importance of maintaining order, protecting rights, and ensuring accountability, they function very differently. While administrative law majorly deals with regulations concerning the functions of public agencies, the process of decision-making and the fact that such agencies be utilizing their lawful powers, constitutional law prescribes the relationship between the citizens and the governments. Constitutional law, however, involves the general framework of the state, defining the structure of government, safeguarding basic rights, and limiting governmental powers.
Are you interested in pursuing a career in Law? The Legal School in collaboration with IndusLaw has created unique programs for a Certification in Mergers & Acquisitions, Private Equity and Venture Capital Laws & Certification in Mergers & Acquisitions for fresh law graduates as well as professionals looking to advance in their careers! Enquire now for details!
What is Administrative Law?
Administrative law refers to the body of law that defines the duties and responsibilities that agencies in government need to perform. It should be noted that the agency ought to operate within the scope of legal frameworks set by legislations and accountability mechanisms. It is a law governing the activities of administrative agencies of government. Administrative law deals with the process of decision-making within an administrative unit, and it includes rule-making adjudication, and enforcement of a regulatory agenda. It aims at regulating and controlling the powers and duties of the authorities of administration.
Purpose:
This is to ensure that public authorities exercise their jurisdictions lawfully and that they stay within their jurisdictions without exceeding them.
Scope:
It encompasses a vast array of fields such as public health, environmental laws, as well as taxation, in which policies are implemented by government agencies.
Mechanism:
The law of administrative order provides relief to the people who are affected by any decision given by the administrative authority.
Features of Administrative Law
Administrative law goes ahead to control and regulate the nature of activities of government agencies so that they operate within their prescribed scope. It allows the legislative power to delegate certain rule-making authority to some administrative authorities and thus offers effective governance.
The courts scrutinize the administrative exercise concerning the legality of standards so that they do not undermine individual rights. Administrative law accommodates the dynamic character of contemporary governance, where agencies continue to respond to specific concerns without necessary constant legislative amendments.
Want to pursue law? Check out the online law courses and fulfill your dreams.
Introduction to Constitutional Law
Constitutional law, however, deals with the provisions and principles provided by the constitution of a country. It describes the framework of the government structure, defines the rights of its people, and controls the relationship between the state and citizens. It is the supreme law of the land and carries more authority than any other action provided by legislation.
Purpose:
Its goal is to ensure the protection of fundamental rights and the proper functioning of government institutions.
Scope:
It includes topics like the separation of powers, the functioning of legislative, executive, and judicial bodies, and the safeguarding of civil liberties.
Mechanism:
Constitutional law has provisions of judicial review whereby courts can invalidate unconstitutional laws and protect citizens' rights.
Features of Constitutional Law
In the rendering of constitutional law, the constitution is supreme in that it becomes the supreme law guiding all governmental actions. It defines the executive, legislative, and judicial functions and powers, which it vests to establish a system of checks and balances. Constitutional law provides rights inherent in all citizens and means by which those rights can be protected against governmental violation. Courts can strike down any law or official act that is construed as violative of the Constitution.
Read to know corporate governance meaning.
Check out the largest FDI investment in India.
Key Differences Between Administrative Law and Constitutional Law
Administrative law and constitutional law are two very considerable portions of public law, but they overlap in many ways in practice. Though both of these sections highly contribute to governing and regulating a country, they are unique from each other due to their scope, purpose, and application.
1. Scope and Domain:
Administrative law deals with the powers, functions, and procedures of government agencies.
Constitutional law deals with the structure of powers and functions of government institutions that the Constitution reserves.
2. Nature:
Administrative law: It is a very specific and procedural law, mainly focusing on day-to-day governance and regulation.
Constitutional law: It is more general and fundamental. It governs principles that should hold the legal system.
3. Rule-making Power:
Administrative law: Administrative authorities are regulated to act within the law to follow the proper procedure.
Constitutional law: The constitutional law regulates inter-branch interaction so that no laws contravene the constitution.
4. Judicial Review:
Administrative law: Judicial Review, in fact, protects the administrative action or a decision from transgressing the boundaries of the jurisdiction of law under administrative law.
Constitutional law: Under constitutional law, judicial review ensures that legislation and the activities of governments are not in conflict with the provisions of the Constitution.
5. Source:
Administrative law derives its origin from statutes, delegated legislation, and judicial decisions.
Constitutional law is directly from the Constitution, and this is the supreme law.
6. Remedy:
Administrative law: Under administrative law, specific remedies usually include cases challenging administrative decisions, such as appeals or reviews.
Constitutional law: Remedies under constitutional law may include issues of challenge to the constitutional validity of laws, protection of fundamental rights, as well as writs such as habeas corpus, mandamus, and certiorari.
7. Objectives and Purpose
Administrative law: Administrative law focuses on the proper conduct of the administration of public authorities and their protection against the unmerited exercise of authority given to them.
Constitutional law: Constitutional law aims at establishing and protecting the legal framework of governance and the rights of individuals in a nation.
AspectAdministrative LawConstitutional LawDefinitionGoverns the actions and decisions of administrative agencies.Governs the fundamental structure, powers, and rights under a constitution.FocusRegulation, powers, and procedures of government agencies.Structure of government, separation of powers, and fundamental rights.Source of LawStatutes, regulations, executive orders, and administrative rules.Constitution, amendments, and judicial interpretations.Key PrinciplesDelegation of power, due process, judicial review of agency actions.Separation of powers, federalism, protection of fundamental rights.ScopeNarrower, applies to specific agencies and administrative decisions.Broader, applies to the entire structure of government and individual rights.Judicial OversightCourts review agency actions for compliance with laws and fairness.Courts review government actions and laws for constitutionality.Primary ObjectiveEnsures agencies act within their authority and follow procedural fairness.Ensures government actions do not violate constitutional principles.Examples of IssuesLicensing, rulemaking, regulatory enforcement, benefits claims.Constitutional rights (e.g., free speech), separation of powers, state vs. federal authority.
Find out the procedure for incorporation of company.
Conclusion
While administrative law and constitutional law are related, they are quite different in their functions in any legal system. It is an administrative law that makes governmental authorities work within the law and responsibly. On the other hand, it is a constitutional law that provides a foundation for the organization of the government and ensures the rights of the individuals. These differences have to be understood by a person studying law, as these two sections form a significant part of any democratic society.
Difference Between Administrative Law and Constitutional Law FAQs
1. Can administrative law override constitutional law?
No, constitutional law overrides all, and no case of administrative law can override the practice of constitutional law.
2. Who enforces administrative law?
Administrative law is enforced by administrative bodies, government agencies, and courts.
3. What is the significance of judicial review in constitutional law?
Judicial review of laws and governmental activity by the courts can ensure that each aligns with constitutional provisions.
4. Is there an overlap between administrative law and constitutional law?
Of course, there is overlap, especially in areas concerning judicial review of administrative decisions and protection of fundamental rights.
5. What happens if there is a conflict between the administrative law and the constitutional law?
In case of a conflict, the constitutional law will prevail because it is superior to the other laws of the land. Any administrative law that goes contrary to the Constitution can be set aside by the courts.
6. Can administrative law create new rights?
No, administrative law principles govern how governmental agencies operate and do not enact new rights. New rights are normally provided for either in a constitutional amendment or by legislation.
