Equality before law and equal protection of the law are probably the two most important principles in almost every legal system for the protection of the rights of all men and the promotion of justice. The principles of equality before the law and equal protection under the law are anchored on the grounds of legal jurisprudence. Both of them are important in making sure that there is justice in a legal system and in a democratic setting. Though related, these concepts are far from one another when talking about application and scope. This paper, in great detail, outlines the difference between equality before law and equal protection of law.
Equality Before Law: Meaning and Scope
Equality before law implies that every individual, be he a high dignitary or a wealthy person or a member of any particular caste or woman, stands in the same relationship with the law. The concept of equality before the law brings to light the absence of any discrimination and status. Such a principle makes sure that every citizen is equal before the law which goes hand in hand as an important component of the rule of law.
Characteristics of Equality before Law:
All persons are equal before the law.
No person has any special privileges or immunity.
Nobody is deemed above the law. This includes government officials or officers holding high offices.
This principle was borrowed from the British common law and emphasizes that citizens are equal before the courts.
Example: In matters of criminal law, a cabinet minister and a common citizen must receive identical treatment from the law.
Equal Protection of Law: Meaning and Scope
Equal protection of law advocates a reasonable classification. This means that there are people on one side whose relevant circumstances - differ categorically from those of others in the same class. Thus, every legal system must treat individuals in like circumstances alike though treating different situations alike is not necessarily required.
This provision gives a wider meaning so that it can allow positive discrimination where such action is necessary to further the cause of justice and equality.
Key Features of Equal Protection of Law:
He treats similar persons or classes equally in the eyes of law.
It allows classification when circumstances call for different treatment, e.g., affirmative action.
The state can enact special laws to uplift disadvantaged communities; to bring social equity
This concept is derived from the 14th Amendment of the Constitution of the USA aiming to maintain fairness in their legal treatment.
Example: Special reservation for Scheduled Castes (SCs) and Scheduled Tribes (STs) in India makes sense through this principle, as these need a push to achieve equal opportunities.
Are you interested in pursuing a career in Law? The Legal School in collaboration with IndusLaw has created a unique 4-month program for a Certification in Mergers & Acquisitions, for fresh law graduates as well as professionals looking to advance in their careers! Enquire now for details!
Difference Between Equality Before Law and Equal Protection of Law
1. Concept
Equality Before Law: Equality Before Law envisages equal treatment of persons without regard to their position.
Equal Protection of Law: Equal Protection of Law entails equality as persons in equal circumstances are treated equally but reasonable classification may be allowed to accord special treatment to the depressed classes.
2. Nature
Equality Before Law: Equality Before Law prohibits any privilege or exceptional benefit to anyone or group of persons.
Equal Protection of Law: Equal Protection of Law allows special treatment to the depressed classes to remove social inequality.
3. Scope
Equality Before Law: Equality before the law applies equally to everyone without bias.
Equal Protection of Law allows for the distinction if such a situation meets legitimate goals, for instance, reservations for the marginalized sections
4. Objective
Equality Before Law: Equality before the law seeks to remove discrimination and is achieved with an equal application of laws.
Equal Protection of Law: The equal protection of law seeks real equality in terms of the social and economic inequalities that exist today.
5. Origin
Equality Before Law: The concept of equality before the law is borrowed from the British jurisprudence system.
Equal Protection of Law: Equal Protection of Law is inspired by the 14th Amendment of the Constitution of the United States of America.
6. Illustration
Equality Before Law: A politician and a common man are punished equally for committing the same crime.
Equal Protection of Law: Reservation policies for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in educational facilities and job opportunities.
7. Relevance
Equality Before Law: Equality Before Law points out that all persons are treated equally by the same law.
Equal Protection of Law: Positive discrimination for attaining equity will be permissible by Equal Protection of Law in terms of recognition of social realities.
8. Complementarity
Equality Before Law: Equality Before Law ensures uniformity in legal treatment.
Equal Protection of Law: Equal Protection of Law ensures fairness by recognising different circumstances and needs.
AspectEquality Before LawEqual Protection of LawDefinitionAll individuals are subject to the same laws.People in similar situations are treated equally.NatureAbsolute equality; no privileges for anyone.Conditional equality; allows reasonable classification.ScopePrevents any arbitrary use of power or privilege.Ensures fairness by recognizing different needs.OriginBased on British law (Rule of Law).Derived from the U.S. Constitution (14th Amendment).ApplicationFocuses on uniform treatment for all individuals.Addresses positive discrimination and social equity.ExampleA politician and an ordinary citizen are tried the same way.Reservations for backward classes in public employment.
Click to find out about law certificate courses!
Constitutional Provisions in India and the United States
India: Article 14 of the Constitution
Article 14 of the Indian Constitution expresses both equality before law and equal protection of laws. Even though these two aspects fall under one article, the protections they extend vary as follows:
Equality Before Law (First part of Article 14): "The State shall not deny to any person equality before the law."
Equal Protection of Laws (Second part of Article 14): "The State shall not deny to any person within the territory of India the equal protection of the laws."
In Indian jurisprudence, the Supreme Court has clarified that whereas equality before law ensures formal equality, equal protection of laws empowers the state to take steps to remedy historical injustices through special provisions (e.g., affirmative action).
United States: Fourteenth Amendment
This is the Equal Protection Clause, the hallmark of the Fourteenth Amendment in the United States. It was designed to prevent the practice of certain discriminatory conduct by individual states, especially after the abolition of slavery. As ratified over time by the U.S. Supreme Court, the clause includes protection against discrimination based on race, gender, sexual orientation, and more recently, nationality.
Relationship between equality before law and equal protection of law
Equality before the law and equal protection of the law each ensure that justice is served, but with different approaches. Whereas equality before the law ensures the same treatment for everyone within the framework of the law, equal protection of law takes this as a pretext to let different groups call for different actions to achieve real fairness. This is in ensuring that equal treatment is seen in the result rather than just in words.
For example, treating everyone in the same manner regardless of past disadvantages merely might continue existing inequality; therefore, equal protection permits affirmative action policies that can bridge the favored and the disfavored groups.
Conclusion
The universal applicability of laws without discrimination is ensured, and fair treatment with recognition of inequalities is ensured by equal protection of the law. These two principles are the pillars of justice and fairness that the Indian Constitution in Article 14 spells down to society. Between equal treatment of all and different realities of individuals and communities, they provide the golden mean. It is in this double approach that one will achieve more in terms of a society that is inclusive and just, equal and also fair.
Difference Between Equality Before Law and Equal Protection of Law FAQs
1. What is the meaning of the phrase "Equality Before Law"?
Equality before law refers to a principle where every individual is subjected to the same laws irrespective of how high or low, or the position that one holds. It ensures formal equality, wherein there is not even a single privilege or discrimination while enforcing the law.
2. What is the meaning of the phrase "Equal Protection of Law"?
"Equal protection of law" promises equal treatment of people under the law, with due consideration to the diversity of circumstances. It propounds substantive equality by offering affirmative discrimination or special treatment of some classes to elevate them to the normal standard.
3. How do Equality Before Law and Equal Protection of Law differ?
The most apparent distinction lies in their fields of application:
Equality Before Law affords equal treatment in the application of the same rule to everyone.
Equal Protection of Law asserts that different treatment should be allowed in unequal circumstances to reach an equal level of justice, such as affirmative action or reservations.
4. Which of the two is more inclusive: equality before law or equal protection of law?
Equal Protection of Law is more inclusive because it surpasses mere uniformity and speaks of equity, where equality would be helped by reasonable classifications as well as special provisions.
5. Are Equality Before Law and Equal Protection of Law found in the Indian Constitution?
Yes, both are provided under Article 14 of the Indian Constitution:
Equality Before Law (first part): It ensures that all persons are equal before the law.
Equal Protection of Laws (second part): It affirms that people in different circumstances may receive special protections for fairness.
