Difference Between Ownership and Possession: Ownership and possession are the basic concepts used in the discussion of property law, as well as legal and philosophical debates. The words are used separately, seemingly with different meanings, though based on the general difference. Ownership connotes full legal title to a thing, while possession relates to the physical control or occupancy of a thing.
Ownership is the highest type of rights over a property. This is where the owner has the actual and legal power to use, transfer, or dispose of it. Possession, on the other hand, is the holding or occupation of a property regardless of whether the possessor has the legal right to it. For example, a tenant in a rented household has possession of the property, but the landlord maintains ownership.
With ownership, all rights are acquired, including selling or even giving away the property; however, with possession, one only has control over the asset without necessarily owning it fully. The two have, hence, been of great importance to law, trade, and especially to real estate transactions and in the settlement of disputes and demarcations of duties.
What is Ownership?
Ownership can be termed the legal right in the possession, use, and alienation of the property. It is essentially the most perfect relation between a human being and property because it vests authority in the owner to transfer or sell the property or even to alter it. Ownership is a concept recognized by law; thus, the law guards the exclusive control of the object unless transferred to some other person through the law.
Essentials of Ownership
Absolute Right: Ownership confers total legal control over an asset, including the right to use or modify it.
Transferability: He can transfer his ownership by selling, inheritance, or gift.
Right to Enjoy and Dispose: The owner has every authority to use the asset, delight in its benefits, and dispose of it in whatever way he wants to do.
Indefinite Duration: It is permanent unless voluntarily transferred or legally revoked.
Deprivation of others: Ownership gives a right to deprive others of interfering with the property, except so authorized by the owner.
Ownership without bodily presence: A person can own property even though he or she is not physically present over it.
Are you interested in pursuing a career in Law? The Legal School in collaboration with IndusLaw has created a unique 4-month program for a Certification in Mergers & Acquisitions, Private Equity and Venture Capital Laws for fresh law graduates as well as professionals looking to advance in their careers! Enquire now for details!
What is Possession?
Physical Custody or Possession: Possession is a fact-based relationship whereby a person exercises actual dominion over property. The existence of this relationship is irrespective of whether the person in possession owns the property legally. Possession may or may not coincide with ownership. For instance, tenants possess property without owning it.
Essential Components of Possession
Corporeal Possession: This entitles a person control over the property, either directly or through another person.
Animus Possidendi: The person possessing must have the animus possidendi, or the intent to control and exclude others.
Possession Without Ownership: A person can have possession but not legal ownership. For example, rental or lease agreements acquire possession without ownership.
Protected by Law: Wrongful possession is also protected against the interference of third parties but not against unlawful interference.
Temporary or Permanent: Possession may be temporary or develop into permanent possession.
Find out about the types of law degrees available!
Difference Between Ownership and Possession in Jurisprudence
Ownership is wholly regarded as a right under jurisprudence, which places it in terms of total control of a thing. Jurists such as Salmond and Austin have defined ownership to be the "relation between a person and an object, which allows the person to enjoy and dispose of it fully." Possession, as such, forms a factual condition. Here, a person exercises physical control or uses the object, though his legal rights vest elsewhere.
The key differences in jurisprudence are:
1. Nature of Right
Ownership: Ownership refers to a legal right that extends toward control, use, and transfer of property.
Possession: Possession is a fact-based relationship between a person and an object. Possession refers to holding custodial benefits with or without statutory authority.
2. Recognition by Law
Ownership: Jurisprudence acknowledges ownership as a right placed under the umbrella of law. It also includes a bundle of rights such as control, enjoyment, and disposal.
Possession: Though not always based on law, it is guarded by law to safeguard the rules of society. Even bad possession is protected from alienation.
3. Importance of Legal vs. Factual Relationship
Ownership: It focuses on legal rights and force.
Possession: It focuses on the factual situation where someone holds or dominates the object.
4. Example in Jurisprudence
Ownership: The owner of a piece of land has a legal right to alienate it either through sale or gift.
Possession: Possession of land by a squatter gives him physical control but no ownership.
Recap of Difference Between Ownership & Possession in Jurisprudence
AspectOwnershipPossessionNature of ConceptLegal right over a property.Factual control or custody of a property.RecognitionRecognized as a legal right.Recognized as a fact, sometimes protected by law.TransferabilityCan be transferred through sale, gift, or inheritance.Possession changes hands without transferring ownership (e.g., rental).DurationPermanent until legally transferred or lost.Often temporary, depending on circumstances.Legal AuthorityOwner has full authority to use, modify, or transfer the property.Possessor may use the property but cannot legally transfer ownership.Protection by LawProtected with legal remedies against interference.Law protects possession even if it lacks legal ownership, to maintain order.ExampleThe owner of a car can sell or rent it.A borrower using the car temporarily possesses it but cannot sell it.
Differences Between Ownership and Possession in Property Law
While the term ownership itself is broad and more related to property law, referring to the comprehensive right of an asset while giving the owner the power to let a third party transfer, sell, or change it, possession deals with who at a particular time occupies or holds the property. While ownership defines the legal title, possession deals with possession even if temporary.
The key differences in property law are:
1. Transferability
Ownership: Passed through legal processes like sale, inheritance, or gift
Possession: Transferred quickly through rental or loan agreements. Does not transfer ownership
2. Duration
Ownership: Ends when the owner freely relinquishes or compels someone else to legally assume it.
Possession: Transitory in cases like lease agreements or rent.
3. Rights
Ownership: Attains absolute disposal and sales and amendment rights.
Possession: Claims a limited right, confined majorly to its utilization and maintenance of the property.
4. Legal Rights
Ownership: Protected at law with remedies against wrongful interference.
Possession: Protected at law even against unlawful dispossession of the rightful owner in some cases.
5. Example in Property Law
Ownership: The landlord owns a house but leases it to a tenant.
Possession: The tenant has possession of the house but does not have title to it and is under obligation to vacate when the tenancy is over.
Recap of Difference Between Ownership and Possession in Property Law
AspectOwnershipPossessionDefinitionLegal title and full right over a property.Control or occupancy of property, regardless of legal title.TransferabilityCan be legally transferred (e.g., sale or inheritance).Possession changes hands easily without ownership transfer (e.g., lease).Rights InvolvedThe owner has the right to sell, lease, or modify the property.The possessor can only use or maintain the property but not transfer it.DurationPermanent until transferred or forfeited.Temporary or subject to agreements (e.g., tenant possession).Legal ProtectionsThe law ensures ownership against wrongful interference.The law protects possession to prevent unlawful dispossession, even from the owner.ExampleA landlord owns a house and can sell it.A tenant possesses the house until the lease ends.
Conclusion
Over two disciplines of jurisprudence and property law, ownership and possession are two dissimilar legal conceptions. Ownership is the supreme right and authority over property, implying the disposal ability, selling, or gifting. Possession, however, is a concept based on physical holding or control, irrespective of whether such holding is legally permitted or not. Understanding these concepts forms a critical part of legal education because, through them, the doctrines are defined that mold the principles governing disputes, property rights, and claims of ownership. Broadly, the concept of ownership stresses legal entitlement, whereas possession stresses physical control.
Difference Between Ownership and Possession FAQs
1. What is the distinction between ownership and possession?
Ownership refers to the legal right of a person to control, use, and dispose of property. Where possession relates to physical control without necessarily being a legal owner.
2. Is ownership allowed only when with possession?
No, possession can occur without ownership when one leases or rents property. The tenant then holds the property temporarily but does not own it.
3. Is possession afforded any legal rights?
For example, ownership is safeguarded against third-party interference. Even wrongful ownership does get legal protection. However, it does not provide the same kind of protection as ownership.
4. How would ownership differ in jurisprudence and property law?
Ownership over jurisprudence: Ownership over property can be absolute control or legal authority. In property law, ownership puts stress on legal title. However, possession seems to focus on who possesses the property at any given time.
5. Can possession become ownership?
In some instances, such as adverse possession, possession for a long period, unchallenged by the owner, is regarded in law as conferring ownership.
