Theft and extortion are two different types of criminal offenses as defined under the Indian Penal Code (IPC). While both indicate unlawful taking of property, their nitty-gritty of methods and intent are as different as chalk and cheese. The difference between theft and extortion must first be understood to further distinguish the gravity of these offenses and how the law deals with them.
This article discusses the meanings, essential elements, legal provisions, examples, and critical differences between theft and extortion. So take us into their definitions and legal contexts to clarify how these crimes are approached.
Are you interested in pursuing a career in Law? The Legal School in collaboration with IndusLaw has created unique programs for a Certification in Mergers & Acquisitions, Private Equity and Venture Capital Laws & Certification in Mergers & Acquisitions for fresh law graduates as well as professionals looking to advance in their careers! Enquire now for details!
Meaning of Theft
Section 378 of the IPC defines theft. That amount of movable property that forms the subject matter of theft is taken away dishonestly from a person, either at the time of taking or immediately before so taking, or immediately after taking, permanently to deprive such person of that property. It seems generally to involve some act of bodily dispossession.
Important Features of Theft:
Theft is defined as the unauthorized taking of another's movable property, containing several critical features that set it apart from other crimes that are even similar to it. These features include intent to defraud, lack of consent, and actual removal of the property.
Dishonest Intention: The intention to appropriate the property to deprive the person of his rights regarding that property should be dishonest. The person committing theft must have an intent to cause wrongful gain or wrongful loss.
Movable Property: The property should be movable, such as a jewel, money, or electronics.
Without Consent: It must be committed without the consent of the owner
Change of Possession: There should be a change of possession of the property from the owner to the offender
Legal Provisions for Theft
As per Section 378 of the IPC, theft is theft. Under Section 379 of the IPC, imprisonment is provided for up to three years or a fine, or both. The law considers the mode and character of the theft, along with the value of the property stolen.
Meaning of Extortion
Extortion is dealt with under Section 383 of the IPC. According to the said offence, a person obtains money, property, or valuable security from another by putting him in fear of injury. The main difference between extortion and theft is the fact that there is some form of compulsion on the part of the victim to hand over his property, which generally arises out of fear or intimidation.
Find out the top criminal lawyers in India.
Key Ingredients of Extortion:
Extortion is obtaining or detaining by force or intimidation property or anything of value from another with intent to permanently deprive. Knowing the basic elements of this crime serves to distinguish it from other crimes, including coercion, like blackmail or fraud.
Fear of Injury: The extortionist makes a rational apprehension of injury to either the victim or any person whom the victim cares about.
Transfer of Property: The victim is forced to transfer property or security due to coercion or threat.
Criminal Intent: As in the case of theft, extortion also comprises criminal intent to effect wrongful gain or loss.
Consent Under Duress: Consent is given under duress and is not voluntary.
Crime is never going to end. So is the demand for criminal lawyers. Check out these criminal law courses to specialise in this field of law.
Statutory Provisions Governing Extortion
Extortion is a criminal offence with the help of Section 383 of the IPC. The law regarding extortion under Section 384 of the IPC states that extortion may be punished with imprisonment for a term which may extend to three years and shall also be liable to fine; or both. The severity of punishment depends on the degree of compulsion and the value of property extorted.
Examples of Theft and Extortion
Example of Theft:
If someone steals a neighbor's bicycle surreptitiously to sell it, then that is theft. The criminal intends to deprive the owner of his property permanently.
Extortion Example
When a person threatens a member of another person's family with physical harm unless he receives a certain amount of money, then that is extortion. The victim gives up his money in fear of other members of his family.
Also, read the difference between robbery and dacoity.
Difference Between Theft and Extortion
Theft and extortion are two serious offenses under the Indian Penal Code (IPC), though they are different in terms of the ways by which a crime may be committed, and not to forget the level of coercion surrounding the offense.
1. Nature of Crime
Theft is the taking of property without authorization. Usually done without the knowledge of the owner, theft is a crime wherein one takes property by other than mere permission. Getting property through intimidation or threat is extortion; it's where the person knows what's happening and lets it do so due to fear.
2. Consent
Theft is committed without the consent of the victim. Now, extortion involves consent, but not that which comes voluntarily. The victim, in fear of being hurt, sacrifices his or her property.
3. Use of Force or Threat
Such activities do not imply any direct and explicit threat or violence, as in the case of theft. However, there is always implied violence related to the fear or intimidation applied in extortion. This would be mainly for instilling the fear of injury against either the victim or some person whom the victim cares about.
4. Type of Property
Theft usually involves movable property, such as money, electronics, or other important valuables. In extortion, the property taken may be movable as well as immovable, with valuable security that could be legal documents or contracts.
5. Mode of Action
Theft is a crime in which the property is forcibly taken away from the owner without his knowledge or consent. In extortion, the victim is compelled to hand over the property out of fear for their safety or the safety of others.
6. Legal Provisions
Theft is defined under sections 378 and 379 of the IPC, whereas extortion is covered under sections 383 and 384 of the IPC. These sections have listed the ingredients of each crime and their respective punishments.
7. Punishment
Both theft and extortion carry the possibility of up to three years in jail, or a fine, or both. However, extortion risks more, depending on its level of coercion or the value extorted.
FactorTheftExtortionDefinitionDishonestly taking movable property without consent.Unlawfully obtaining property by putting someone in fear.ConsentWithout consent.With coerced consent due to fear or threat.Use of Force/ThreatNo force or threat was involved.Involves threats or fear of injury.Property TypeMovable property (e.g., jewelry, vehicles).Movable and immovable property or valuable security.Legal ProvisionSection 378 and 379 of the IPC.Section 383 and 384 of the IPC.PunishmentUp to 3 years imprisonment, fine, or both.Up to 3 years imprisonment, fine, or both.
Want to know how much a criminal lawyer earns? Check out a criminal lawyer salary.
Conclusion
While both theft and extortion involve the illegal acquisition of property belonging to another, their approaches and legal consequences differ. Theft refers to the secret taking of property without permission, while extortion uses threat and fear to compel the person into giving them his or her property. Understanding these basic legal differences protects your rights and ensures justice when such crimes occur.
Difference Between Theft and Extortion FAQs
1. Can theft and extortion exist simultaneously?
No, because they are two different crimes. Theft refers to taking away property without, or against, the wish of the owner, whereas extortion refers to compelling a person to yield property out of fear.
2. What is the most significant difference between theft and extortion?
Theft refers to taking away property without consent, whereas extortion refers to obtaining it by threats or fear.
3. What is the punishment for extortion under Indian law?
Under Section 384 of the IPC, extortion may extend to imprisonment for three years, or fine, or both.
4. What nature of property does theft and extortion cover?
Generally, theft would deal with movable properties; in the case of extortion, both movable and immovable properties as well as securities could be involved.
5. Is there consent in theft as well as in extortion?
Yes, but in the act of theft, no consent is involved, as in extortion, it is given under duress or fear.
