International trade relies on contracts which function as legally enforceable documents that outline the responsibilities and rights of each party involved. Due to the challenges associated with cross-border transactions which include multiple legal systems and differing languages and business customs international trade law establishes a cohesive system to enable contract creation and execution.
The United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG) is the primary legal instrument governing international sales contracts. UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts and lex mercatoria (general principles of international trade law) also play significant roles in shaping contract formation under international trade law.
Elevate your career with a 4-month Contract Drafting & Negotiation Certification focusing on AI tools. Gain expertise in drafting contracts across sectors, handling negotiations, and mastering contract life cycle management.
Legal Framework for Contract Formation
International trade contracts fall under the regulations of international conventions and model laws as well as national legal systems. The standardized rules for offer acceptance and contract enforcement within these frameworks facilitate more efficient cross-border trade transactions.
1. The CISG (United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods)
The CISG, adopted in 1980, is the most widely accepted international convention governing contract formation in cross-border sales of goods. Over 95 countries have ratified the CISG, making it the default legal framework for many international sales contracts.
Scope and Applicability
The CISG applies to contracts for the sale of goods between businesses in different countries, provided both countries are signatories to the CISG.
It does not cover services, consumer goods, auctions, securities, ships, aircraft, and electricity contracts.
The parties can choose to exclude or modify the application of the CISG by mutual agreement.
Formation of Contracts under the CISG
The CISG sets clear rules for offer, acceptance, and modification of contract terms.
(a) Offer (Article 14)
An offer under the CISG must meet three essential conditions:
Intent to be Bound: The offeror must intend to be bound if accepted.
Definiteness – The offer must include essential elements, such as:
A description of the goods.
The quantity to be sold.
The price or a method to determine it.
Communication to the Offeree: The offer must be directed to a specific person or group.
(b) Acceptance (Articles 18-21)
Acceptance must be clear, timely, and communicated effectively to the offeror:
Manner of Acceptance: It can be in writing, verbal, or inferred from conduct (e.g., shipment of goods).
Time Limit for Acceptance: The offer must be accepted within the specified time frame or a reasonable period.
Silence is NOT Acceptance: If the offeree does not respond, it does not imply acceptance.
(c) Modifications and Counteroffers (Article 19)
If the offeree modifies the terms of the offer, it is considered a counteroffer rather than an acceptance.
However, the offer may still be valid if the modifications are not material.
Material modifications include changes in price, payment terms, quality, quantity, delivery terms, and liability.
(d) Revocation of Offers (Article 16)
An offer can be revoked before the acceptance reaches the offeror.
However, if the offer states that it is irrevocable for a specific period, it cannot be withdrawn.
(e) Contract Conclusion (Article 23)
A contract is considered concluded when the acceptance of an offer becomes effective.
Know What are the 10 Essential Elements of a Valid Contract
2. UNIDROIT Principles of International Commercial Contracts
The UNIDROIT Principles, developed by the International Institute for the Unification of Private Law (UNIDROIT), provide a more flexible, non-binding framework that can be used in international trade contracts.
Key Principles in Contract Formation:
Freedom of Contract – Parties have the freedom to negotiate and agree on the terms of their contract.
Binding Nature of Offers – As in the CISG, offers have to be with definite terms and an intention to be bound.
Silence as Acceptance – Silence or doing nothing can sometimes amount to acceptance provided it conforms to previous conduct between the parties.
Electronic Contracts – In contrast to common law, UNIDROIT unambiguously acknowledges formation by electronic communications.
While the UNIDROIT Principles are not legally binding unless explicitly incorporated into a contract, they are a guiding tool for international trade disputes and arbitration.
Find out Is Contract Management a Good Career?
3. Common Law vs. Civil Law Approaches to Contract Formation
Different legal traditions impact contract formation in international trade.
Common Law Approach (e.g., U.S., U.K.)
Contracts must satisfy offer, acceptance, consideration, and intention to create legal relations.
The "mirror image rule" applies: the acceptance must be an exact match to the offer. Otherwise, it is considered a counteroffer.
Consideration (something of value exchanged) is essential for a valid contract.
Civil Law Approach (e.g., France, Germany, China)
Acceptance does not have to be an exact match; minor modifications may still lead to a valid contract.
Consideration is not a strict requirement.
Contracts can be binding based on mutual consent and intention.
The CISG serves as a bridge between these two legal traditions, harmonizing the rules on contract formation.
4. Contract Formation in International Trade and Technology
The development of modern technology resulted in new contract formation methods that include electronic contracts and smart contracts.
Electronic Contracts (E-Contracts)
E-commerce together with digital contracts now serves as the foundation for international trade expansion.
The UNCITRAL Model Law on Electronic Commerce and the Electronic Communications Convention (ECC) support electronic contract formation.
Electronic signatures (e.g., DocuSign, blockchain-based signatures) are widely recognized in international trade.
Smart Contracts in International Trade
Smart contracts use blockchain technology to execute contract terms automatically.
They are self-enforcing and reduce the need for intermediaries.
While promising, legal challenges remain regarding enforceability under traditional contract law.
Also, Get to Know How to Draft a Business Contract
Challenges in Contract Formation under International Trade Law
Despite harmonized rules, specific challenges persist in forming contracts internationally:
Jurisdictional Issues: Determining which country's laws apply in case of disputes.
Language Barriers: Misinterpretations in contract terms due to different languages.
Cultural Differences: Business customs and negotiation styles vary across countries.
Dispute Resolution: Arbitration vs. litigation; selecting a neutral governing law.
Enforceability: Making contracts identified and enforceable across several jurisdictions.
Summing Up
International trade law regulates contract formation through CISG which establishes standardized procedures for making offers and accepting them along with modifying contract terms for international sales. The UNIDROIT Principles extend this legal framework by delivering supplemental guidelines that parties can use to maintain neutrality and clarity throughout their contractual dealings.
Related Posts:
Formation of Contract under International Trade Law: FAQs
Q1: What are smart contracts and their implications in international trade?
Smart contracts are computerized digital agreements on a blockchain. Smart contracts execute themselves automatically but raise enforceability concerns legally.
Q2: What are the major impediments in contract formation for international contracts?
Jurisdiction, language, cultural aspects, mechanism for dispute resolution, and enforcement of contracts are primary challenges.
Q3: Whether silence is to be accepted in international trade law?
Silence is not an acceptance under the CISG, unless there is prior business practice to the contrary.
Q4: What are the methods of dispute resolution for international contracts?
Common methods are international arbitration (e.g., ICC, UNCITRAL), mediation, and litigation in a neutral forum.
Q5: How can businesses have enforceable international contracts?
By defining contract terms clearly, selecting a governing law, employing dispute resolution clauses, and complying with international legal systems such as the CISG.
