Copyright is an integral aspect of intellectual property law that guards the creative and intellectual work of a person or organization. Indian copyright law has developed extensively over time, and the same has responded to technological changes and expanded digital platforms. This paper deals with the punishment for copyright infringement in India, meaning what it is that punishment for copyright infringement is, legislative framework, types of copyright infringement, and penalties associated with them. We will also see case law relevant to the matter and practical measures that might be taken against copyright infringement.
Introduction
Modernizing rapid technological changes have not only provided the masses with better avenues to access copyrighted work, but also facilitated copyright and pirated copies through equally accessible means. This phenomenon of copyright infringement implies making or using the work or another, without permission, hence damaging the rights of workmanship or authorship as envisaged in the original work done. Copyright law in India has been provided for through Copyright Act, 1957. It protects several items, including literary works; dramatic, musical, artistic, and others. It also provides the creator, business, and consumer with an understanding of copyright infringement punishment and remedy.
Copyright and Copyright Infringement
Copyright extends legal protection to original works' creators and grants them exclusive rights over the use, reproduction, distribution, and performance of such work. Works that can be copyrighted include books, music, films, paintings, software, and a whole lot more. This is done to encourage creativity and innovation as creators get recognition and monetary benefits from their works.
Copyright infringement takes place when one violates the above rights without permission from a copyright holder. Examples, though not limited to, are unauthorized copying, distribution, public presentation, or adaptation of copyrighted works. As a result, copyright infringement falls into two broad types.
Direct Infringement: Directly uses without permission or license somebody else's copyright material; this includes: copying out a book; using sound recording in commercial without first getting a license to do it; and streaming movies online or through other mediums without someone's permission to do the same.
Secondary Infringement: Secondary infringement arises if a party indirectly abets or enables copyright infringement. An example would be hosting such a site which provides pirated content or manufacture of such devices that bypass the copyright protection.
Legislative Framework Governing Copyright Infringement in India
In India, the copyright law is governed by the Copyright Act, 1957 and its amendments that have been made since. The Act defines the scope of copyright, rights available to copyright owners, and the liabilities for infringement. Significant provisions of the Act applicable to infringement are:
Section 51 – Deals with infringement and provides what situations give rise to copyright as being infringed.
Section 63 – Relates to criminal liability for infringement of copyright.
Section 55 – Civil remedies, injunctions, damages, and accounts of profits.
India is also a signatory to several international treaties and agreements, such as the Berne Convention, the TRIPS Agreement (Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights), and the WIPO Copyright Treaty, which determine its copyright laws and standards.
Are you interested in pursuing a career in Law? The Legal School in collaboration with IndusLaw has created a unique program for a Certification in Mergers & Acquisitions, Private Equity and Venture Capital Laws for fresh law graduates as well as professionals looking to advance in their careers! Enquire now for details!
Types of Punishments for Copyright Infringement in India
India's Copyright Act, 1957, makes available criminal as well as civil remedies for infringement of copyright. The crime generally depends on the nature of copyright infringement, intention, and harm caused to the copyright owner.
1. Criminal Punishment
According to the Copyright Act, copyright infringement is considered a criminal offense for which specific provisions have outlined the punishments to be accorded to offenders:
Imprisonment: Section 63 of the Act states that a copyright infringement carries a minimum sentence of six months' imprisonment which may extend up to three years. The extent of the imprisonment is determined by the seriousness of the offense, the intent, and other circumstances.
Fines: In addition to imprisonment, offenders can be ordered to pay a fine that could fall anywhere between INR 50,000 and INR 200,000. The imposition of the fine is accordingly intended to deter infringement and prevent loss in revenue that might have been suffered by the copyright owner.
Enhanced Punishment for Repeat Offenders: Section 63A of the Act prescribes enhanced punishment for repeat offenders, where subsequent convictions can attract a minimum of one year's imprisonment that can go up to three years and fines ranging from INR 100,000 to INR 200,000.
Seizure and Forfeiture of Infringing Goods: The Act allows the authorities to seize infringing copies and any materials used in the making of them. This can include equipment used in duplicating copyrighted material or pirated digital content.
Criminal remedies serve two purposes they deter unauthorized use of copyrighted material and protect the rights of creators.
2. Civil Remedies
In relation to criminal penalties, copyright owners also have civil remedies. The civil actions are given according to section 55 of the Copyright Act as follows;
Injunctions: A copyright owner can seek an injunction to prevent continuing infringement of the copyrighted work. The court can make temporary or permanent injunctions to cease the infringement.
Damages and Accounts of Profits: Damages or account of profits will be recoverable by copyright owner. Here, damages will be measured on account of loss caused due to copyright infringement; however the account of profits will permit the copyright owner to recover his profits as received by the infringer.
Handing Over Infringing Copies: The infringing party can be directed to deliver all the infringing copies along with other materials so that they do not spread further.
Know about various law exams in India!
Factors Influencing Punishment Severity
Degree of punishment for copyright violations in India varies with such factors as:
Nature of Infringement: Commercial exploitations of infringing work, for example, major piracy usually attract severe retribution compared to individual actions.
Extent of Harm: The more extensive is the loss caused to the copyright owner financially, more is likely to be determined for fines and other compensatory remedies.
Intentions: As usual, offenses based on the intent and for purpose are generally held to be grave ones, where the punishment is handed over quite stringently
Repeat offenders: Repeaters receive even graver penalties that can take the shape of imposition of higher compensation amount along with longer imprisonment duration.
Also, read about Criminal Law Courses in India!
Key Copyright Infringement Judgments under the Indian Laws
It involves analyzing landmark cases, which have shaped Indian copyright jurisprudence, in determining the judicial approach toward copyright infringement.
India TV Independent News Service Pvt. Ltd. v. Yashraj Films Pvt. Ltd. (2013):
Delhi High Court held that the copyright owner is entitled to display his work, and his exclusive right to authorize or prevent the broadcasting of his work. In the facts of the present case, India TV possessed some clips of a movie without obtaining any prior approval from the copyright holder which resulted in a decree of damages in favor of the copyright holder.
Super Cassettes Industries Ltd. v. Hamar TV (2011):
The judgment restated that the playing of copyrighted owner's songs without obtaining permission from him amounts to infringement. The court granted permanent injunction and awarded damages and stated the financial cost that resulted from non-authorised use of the content.
Eastern Book Company v. D.B. Modak (2008):
The Supreme Court ruled here that judgments pronounced by courts cannot be copyrighted, but the compilation of judgments in a unique form, such as a law report, could be copyrighted.
Preventive Steps against Copyright Infringement:
The rights of copyright owners can be prevented from infringement with the following preventive measures:
Registering Copyright: Copyright is automatic in India; however, registration would add an extra layer of protection, and it also would help the owner to prove ownership before a court of law.
Technological Protection Measures (TPM): The use of digital tools like watermarking, encryption, and DRM will make pirated content useless or will prevent further unauthorized copying and distribution.
Education to Consumers: Increasing consumer awareness about the consequences of copyright infringement would reduce the demand for pirated copies.
Applying Online Protections: Copyrights enforcement is required in the cyber world. Copyright owners track down websites and platforms from where piracy is happening. Thus, they can take any required actions legally.
Public-Private Partnership: The government or law enforcement agencies and the private companies, such as ISP providers, can assist copyright holders against the pirates.
Conclusion
Copyright infringement in India is dealt strictly, and it has the possibility of severe penalties through fines or imprisonment depending on the degree of the offense. The dual structure of criminal and civil remedies under the Copyright Act, 1957 is strong enough for creators with long enough frightening off potential infringers. The new wave of digitized content and online distribution raised new challenges in enforcing copyright law.
The copyright holder must always be vigilant to protect the copyright interest by taking both legal and technological steps to combat infringement. For that, India must develop a balanced approach which respects the rights of creators and provides public access to knowledge.
Punishment for Copyright Infringement FAQs
1. What is copyright infringement in India?
Copyright infringement in India is the unauthorized use, reproduction, or distribution of a copyrighted work without permission from the copyright owner. This includes copying, sharing, or displaying protected works without authorization and therefore violating the copyright owner's exclusive rights.
2. What are the penalties for copyright infringement in India?
The India Copyright law prescribes penalties that have the nature of both civil and criminal laws. Civil remedies are granted under injunctions, damages accompanied by an order requiring either destruction or seizure of all the infringing copies. Criminal offenses involve imprisonment for an amount of six months extendable up to three years, along with a fine, which varies from INR 50,000 and reaches up to INR 200,000.
3. What are the sorts of copyright infringement defined?
Copyright infringement is normally classified as direct and indirect. It involves copyright material used without permission, copying the said material. The latter form of copyright infringement involves hosting pirated content or merely aiding the infringement in the process.
4. What are the laws about copyright infringement in India?
The Copyright Act, 1957 is primarily a defining legislation on Indian copyright law, stating what are the rights of a copyright owner, how an infringement is defined, and the penalty attached. In addition to these agreements affecting Indian copyright, there is the Berne Convention and the TRIPS Agreement.
5. Is there imprisonment for copyright in India?
Copyright infringement can indeed entail prison time. Copyright Act makes a minimum provision of imprisonment for six months, extended up to three years by the nature of the committed infringement.
