Section 19 of the Companies Act, 2013 largely deals with the prohibition of a subsidiary company to hold shares in its holding company. According to that, neither a subsidiary can hold directly or through nominees the shares in its holding company, nor can allotment or transfer of any shares of the holding company be accepted in the subsidiary. Such transactions are held to be void. More specifically, exceptions include where a subsidiary holds shares as a legal representative of a deceased member, as a trustee, or if it held the shares before becoming a subsidiary. It further states that subsidiaries holding shares under these exceptions can vote in the holding company's meetings, but only in respect of the shares held under these specific circumstances. This ensures proper governance and prevents conflicts of interest within corporate structures.

Purpose of Section 19 of the Companies Act 2013

• Prevents Conflicts of Interest: Prevents subsidiaries from holding shares in the parent since they may conflict and manipulate the financial statements.

• Maintain Corporate Governance: Aim to have transparent and straightforward corporate governance for all group firms.

• Prevents Undue Influence by a Subsidiary Company: a subsidiary company prevents undue influence on the process of decision-making of its parents.

Detailed Breakdown of Section 19 of the Companies Act 2013

Here's a detailed breakdown of Section 19 of the Companies Act 2013:

Sub-section (1): Prohibition and Void Transfer

• Prohibition of Holding Shares by Subsidiary Companies: A subsidiary company shall not hold shares in its holding company. The subsidiary company shall not, directly or through nominees, hold shares in its holding company.

• Prohibition of Allotment or Transfer: No holding company is permitted to issue allot shares or transfer its shares to any subsidiary companies.

• Void Transfers: All the shares of a holding company standing at the credit of subsidiary company, if issued or transferred in contravention of this section, shall be void.

First Proviso to Sub-section (1): Exceptions to Prohibitions

• Exception for Legal Representatives: A subsidiary can hold shares in its holding company if it does so as the legal representative of a deceased member of the holding company.

• Exception for Trustees: A subsidiary may hold shares as a trustee.

• Shares Held Prior to Becoming a Subsidiary: A subsidiary that held shares of any company prior to the time when it became a subsidiary of that company is excluded from this section.

Second Proviso to Sub-section (1): Voting Rights

Voting Rights: Where a subsidiary holds shares in the holding company within the circumstances described in the first proviso either as a legal representative or trustee, it shall be granted the right to vote at the meetings of the holding company, but only in regard to those shares that it holds as a legal representative or trustee.

Know Stages in Incorporating a Company

Sub-section (2): Application to Companies Without Share Capital

Companies Limited by Guarantee or Unlimited Companies: If the holding company is a company limited by guarantee or an unlimited company that does not have share capital, references in this section to 'shares' are deemed to be references to the interests of the members of the holding company, as those interests are expressed.

Know in detail about best law certificate courses to upskill in 2024

Illustration on Section 19 of the Companies Act 2013

Imagine a company called TreeTop Holdings, which owns several subsidiaries, including Leafy Foods and Branch Crafts. To maintain clear corporate governance and prevent financial manipulation, the law stipulates under Section 19 of the Companies Act that:

1. Leafy Foods cannot hold shares in TreeTop Holdings either directly or through nominees. This prevents Leafy Foods from influencing decisions at TreeTop that could benefit Leafy disproportionately to the detriment of TreeTop and its other subsidiaries.

2. TreeTop Holdings is also restricted from allocating shares to Leafy Foods or Branch Crafts. Any shares inadvertently given to a subsidiary would be legally void, meaning they would have no effect and could not confer any rights typically associated with share ownership, such as voting.

3. There are exceptions, however:

• If Leafy Foods inherits shares of TreeTop Holdings as a legal representative of a deceased member’s estate, it can hold these shares.

• If Leafy Foods acts as a trustee holding TreeTop shares on behalf of another party, this is also permissible.

• If Leafy Foods already owned shares in TreeTop Holdings before it became a subsidiary, it can retain these shares but may only vote with them under specific circumstances, ensuring that it does not have undue influence on the parent company's decisions.

Are you interested in pursuing a career in Law? The Legal School in collaboration with IndusLaw has created unique programs for a Certification in Mergers & Acquisitions, Private Equity and Venture Capital Laws & Certification in Mergers & Acquisitions for fresh law graduates as well as professionals looking to advance in their careers! Enquire now for details!

In Summary,

Section 19 of the Companies Act 2013 prevents a subsidiary company from holding shares in its holding company either directly or through nominees. Under this provision, there cannot be domination by the subsidiary company over its holding company. The exceptions available are when the subsidiary company holds shares as a legal representative of a deceased member or as a trustee. Other shares held at the time of becoming subsidiary are exempt but voting rights for those shares are limited to specific terms. The basic idea is to maintain lines of authority lucid and free from possible conflicts of interest within corporate hierarchies.

FAQs on Section 19 of the Companies Act 2013

Q1. What is the purpose of Section 19 of the Companies Act 2013?

Section 19 bars the subsidiary from holding shares in its holding company to avoid possible conflicts of interest and transparent governance.

Q2. Can Section 19 allow a subsidiary at all times to hold shares in its holding company?

Yes, a subsidiary may own shares in such cases: where it is acting as an executor of a deceased member's estate, as a trustee, or simply because it owned shares prior to the transaction that made it a subsidiary.

Q3. What happens if a holding company mistakenly distributes shares to a subsidiary?

 Shares issued or transferred in breach of Section 19 are void i.e., h they have no legal effect.

Q4. Does Section 19 permit a subsidiary to vote using its shares in the holding company?

A subsidiary may only vote using the shares if it is held as a legal representative or trustee, or if the shares were vested before it became a subsidiary.

Q5. Does Section 19 of the Companies Act attract penalties for breaching Section 19?

Under this Act, no specific penalties are stipulated under Section 19 for some of the actions in violating the holding shares, but such actions may possibly attract broader legal and regulatory sanctions for failing to meet the governance requirements of the Act.